python version 3.8.6
numpy version 1.19.2
sklearn version 0.23.2

Q:我知道r2_score表示的是在总变量中模型解释的百分比。但是explained_variance_score和它有什么区别?
A:从公式的差别角度看:

当残差的均值为0时,它俩是一样的。至于用哪个,就看你有没有假设残差均值为0。
——Answered by CT Zhu:


一、先举个残差均值不为0的栗子:
import numpy as np
from sklearn import metrics

y_true = [3, -0.5, 2, 7]
y_pred = [2.5, 0.0, 2, 8]
print(metrics.explained_variance_score(y_true, y_pred))
print(metrics.r2_score(y_true, y_pred))

# 结果如下
0.9571734475374732
0.9486081370449679

# 注意:此处残差的均值不为0
print((np.array(y_true) - np.array(y_pred)).mean())
# 结果如下
-0.25
  • explained_variance_score 和r^2其实是:

explained_variance_score=1−Variance(Yture−Ypred)VarianceYtrueexplained\_variance\_score = 1- \frac{ Variance_{(Y_{ture}-Y_{pred})} }{Variance_{Y_{true}}}explained_variance_score=1VarianceYtrueVariance(YtureYpred)

r2=1−∑SquaredResidualsNVarianceYtrue=1−∑SquaredResidualsN∗VarianceYtruer2 = 1-\frac{\frac{\sum SquaredResiduals}{N}}{Variance_{Y_{true}}} = 1-\frac{\sum SquaredResiduals}{N * Variance_{Y_{true}}}r2=1VarianceYtrueNSquaredResiduals=1NVarianceYtrueSquaredResiduals

重点是: Variance(Yture−Ypred)=∑SquaredResiduals−MeanErrorNVariance_{(Y_{ture}-Y_{pred})}=\frac{ \sum SquaredResiduals-MeanError}{N}Variance(YtureYpred)=NSquaredResidualsMeanError。注:此处MeanError实质上取绝对值abs(MeanError)。

# 上边的例子用numpy这样实现:
explained_variance_score = 1- np.var( np.array(y_true)-np.array(y_pred) ) / np.var(y_true)
r2 = 1 - ((np.array(y_true) - np.array(y_pred))**2).sum() / (4 * np.array(y_true).var())    

print(explained_variance_score)
print(r2)

# 结果如下
0.9571734475374732
0.9486081370449679

1) r2分母4 * np.array(y_true).var() 的另一种解释:
依据R2 = 1 - Sum_of_Squares_for_Error/ Sum_of_Squares_for_Total,所以 分母应是总方差SST,即 4 * np.array(y_true).var() = ((y - y.mean())**2).sum(),其中,y 代表 np.array(y_true)

2) explained_variance_score = 1 - np.cov( np.array(y_pred)-np.array(y_true) )/np.cov(y_true)

二、再举个残差均值为0的栗子:
y_ture = [3, -0.5, 2, 7]
y_pred = [2.5, 0.0, 2, 7]

print((np.array(y_true) - np.array(y_pred)).mean())
# 结果如下
0.0

print(metrics.explained_variance_score(y_true, y_pred))
print(metrics.r2_score(y_true, y_pred))
# 结果入下
0.9828693790149893
0.9828693790149893

备注:对于一维数据, 协方差cov/方差var的区别仅仅是自由度的区别,或者说是前者是样本方差,后者是总体方差。例如:

a = [1, 2, 3, 45]
print(np.cov(a))
print(np.var(a)*len(a)/(len(a)-1))   # 即 cov=离差的平方/(样本数 -1),var=离差平方/(样本数)
 # 结果如下:
 462.91666666666663
 462.9166666666667

从含义的差别角度看:Answered by Yahya:
  • 先看R2 / 可决系数 / 判定系数:

– 从公式上看:Variancetrue_y x R2true_y = Variancepred_y,很明显R2越接近1,效果越好。

– R2的含义,是从最小二乘(就是2次方差)的角度出发,表示实际y值的方差有多大比重被预测y值解释了。

Logo

有“AI”的1024 = 2048,欢迎大家加入2048 AI社区

更多推荐